CLIMATE SMART MISSOULA

  • Home
  • Who We Are
    • Our Story
    • People + Partners >
      • Smarty Pants Awards
    • Annual Report
    • In the News >
      • Missoula Current Column
      • Press Releases
    • Podcasts
    • Jobs and Opportunities
    • Blog
  • Resiliency
    • Overview >
      • Climate Ready Missoula Plan
    • Heat >
      • Heat + Health Risks
      • Staying Cool
      • Shade
    • Smoke + Wildfires >
      • Health Risks
      • Clean Indoor Air
      • Fire Ready
    • Urban Forestry
    • Health >
      • Mental Health
    • Water + Ecosystems
  • Mitigation
    • Overview >
      • Community Action Plan
    • 100 % Clean Electricity
    • Solar >
      • Solar Ease
    • Buildings 4 the Future >
      • Electrify
      • Accelerate Clean Energy with the IRA
      • Energy Smart
      • Workforce Coalition
    • Transportation + Smart Growth >
      • Land Use Planning
      • Electric Vehicles
      • Electric Bikes
      • Electric Buses
    • Financing
    • Water + Energy Nexus
    • Zero Waste
  • Get Involved
    • What Can I Do?
    • Calendar + Events >
      • Full Calendar
      • Electrify Homes Tour
      • Climate & Clean Energy Expo
      • Climate Solutions Week
    • 2025 MT Legislature
    • Connect with us >
      • Volunteer Opportunities
    • Act, Advocate, Invest
    • Footprint Fund
  • The Science
    • Overview
    • Climate Justice >
      • Justice and Indigenous Knowledge
    • Local Impacts
  • Donate
  • Contact Us
  • Home
  • Who We Are
    • Our Story
    • People + Partners >
      • Smarty Pants Awards
    • Annual Report
    • In the News >
      • Missoula Current Column
      • Press Releases
    • Podcasts
    • Jobs and Opportunities
    • Blog
  • Resiliency
    • Overview >
      • Climate Ready Missoula Plan
    • Heat >
      • Heat + Health Risks
      • Staying Cool
      • Shade
    • Smoke + Wildfires >
      • Health Risks
      • Clean Indoor Air
      • Fire Ready
    • Urban Forestry
    • Health >
      • Mental Health
    • Water + Ecosystems
  • Mitigation
    • Overview >
      • Community Action Plan
    • 100 % Clean Electricity
    • Solar >
      • Solar Ease
    • Buildings 4 the Future >
      • Electrify
      • Accelerate Clean Energy with the IRA
      • Energy Smart
      • Workforce Coalition
    • Transportation + Smart Growth >
      • Land Use Planning
      • Electric Vehicles
      • Electric Bikes
      • Electric Buses
    • Financing
    • Water + Energy Nexus
    • Zero Waste
  • Get Involved
    • What Can I Do?
    • Calendar + Events >
      • Full Calendar
      • Electrify Homes Tour
      • Climate & Clean Energy Expo
      • Climate Solutions Week
    • 2025 MT Legislature
    • Connect with us >
      • Volunteer Opportunities
    • Act, Advocate, Invest
    • Footprint Fund
  • The Science
    • Overview
    • Climate Justice >
      • Justice and Indigenous Knowledge
    • Local Impacts
  • Donate
  • Contact Us

Climate Smart Missoula's Blog

Letting it all out: responding to climate doom and gloom

7/25/2017

0 Comments

 
PictureYes, we know - but how do we respond?
A couple weeks ago, New York Magazine published a detailed and downright terrifying account of worst-case projected climate impacts that represent the upper limit of current scientific models. The article stirred up a social media firestorm and quickly spawned a range of reactions from climate scientists, journalists, and academics. Interestingly, most critiques were aimed at the tone and framing of the article rather than its accuracy. Some argued that this apocalyptic, doomsday narrative was so depressing it would never motivate people to action; others suggested that this kind of alarmism is precisely what we need to shock us into urgent response to the climate crisis. So which is it? How can we contemplate and understand the real risks that climate change poses, without being paralyzed or overwhelmed by anxiety? Is fear useful? I found myself pondering these questions all last week.

Meanwhile, on Friday night I watched “Inside Out”, the recent animated film about the emotional journey of a young girl, Riley, from childhood into early adolescence, told from the point of view of her emotions themselves: Anger, Fear, Disgust, Sadness, and Joy. If you haven’t seen it, do! It’s one of those kid movies that’s definitely not just for kids. As I watched, I was impressed by the subtle genius of the story and how it illustrates the complexities of our human responses to the world around us. In “Inside Out”, all the emotions play their own important roles at different times. In the end, Sadness and Joy end up working together to motivate Riley’s reconnection with her family. The more I thought about it, the more I realized these messages might offer some wisdom to those of us wrestling with how to respond to climate science and solutions. Skeptical that a cartoon can help? Fair enough - just indulge me for a moment here.  

In the movie, the stress and shock of a cross-country move jolts Sadness and Joy out of Riley’s “control room”, leaving Disgust, Fear, and Anger, haplessly at the helm. With only this limited range of emotions, Riley lashes out at her parents, withdraws into herself, and even tries to run away. If you read that New York Magazine article, maybe this kind of response sounds familiar. Disgust at the damage we have done to our planet, fear of harm to myself and loved ones, anger that we are not acting fast enough to prevent these extreme outcomes - these were certainly the first emotions I felt. Maybe it’s no surprise that critics accused author David Wallace-Wells of exaggeration, fear-mongering, or despairing. When we’re presented with shocking information, it’s natural to try to find a way to discount it or run away from it. 

But here’s the thing about “Inside Out”. Disgust, Fear, and Anger are useful, for a while - they help Riley explore her boundaries and learn about herself, and they can help us ask good questions and not settle for simple answers to complex problems. But they aren’t the only emotions that have a say. Just as Sadness and Joy make their way back to the control room by working as a team, and then proceed to help all of Riley’s emotions work together, we also can’t forget to let sadness and joy inform our responses to climate change. 
Picture
Feeling ALL the emotions.
Sadness and joy are two sides of the same coin: our love for the world and our delight in its wonders is what makes us sad to see it changing! Not to get too sappy, but I believe that acknowledging and giving space for both deep sadness and joy can truly motivate us to action. It can help us harness all our emotions, to see solutions more clearly, and to work together to protect each other and the world we love. ​
​
One last thing - some critics of the article said, “Where’s the hope?” It's true - let’s not forget that the reason why this doomsday scenario is unlikely to play out is that people across the globe are putting creative climate solutions into action, through individual and collective efforts. We’ve been reading some interesting articles on this topic too - stay tuned for another blog soon. 
​

In the end, of all the responses to the original NY Magazine article, journalist David Roberts’ cool-headed analysis seems pretty spot on to me - check it out if you haven’t. The gist: some fear is ok. It’s important to be informed by the latest climate science and models, but it’s worth remembering that we’re only human, and our emotions are real and valid. When we let our emotions do their jobs, we can move forward and find solutions - and hope - together.

​-Abby

0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Authors

    Abby Huseth
    ​Amy Cilimburg
    Caroline Lauer
    Mason Dow
    ​Kelli Littleton
    Hailey Jorgensen
    ​Terri Nichols
    ​Max Longo
    ​Mattie Lehman
    Anna Weinberg

    Archives

    October 2024
    July 2024
    June 2024
    April 2024
    March 2024
    November 2023
    August 2023
    March 2023
    January 2023
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    April 2021
    August 2020
    June 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    January 2020
    October 2019
    September 2019
    May 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    November 2018
    October 2018
    August 2018
    June 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016

    Categories

    All
    Bicycling
    Clean Energy
    Climate Change
    Climate Resiliency
    Community
    DearTomorrow
    Earth Day
    Electrification
    Energy Efficiency
    Food Systems
    Forestry
    Health
    Heat
    Inflation Reduction Act
    Local Food And Agriculture
    Monthly Meetups
    Policy
    Recycling
    Renewable Energy
    Shade
    Smart Growth
    Solar
    Summer Smart
    Transportation
    Trees
    Urban Forests
    Volunteer Opportunities
    Water
    Zero Waste

    RSS Feed

Picture

Connect with us! 

Picture
Picture